Long Island Brothers NY Pizzeria FINAL L

Lunch Specials

11:00a – 3p Daily

1 Slice & Drink....4.50

2 Slices & Drink..6.50

By The Slice


Cheese…....…… 2.95

 (Add toppings)  .25 each


Sicilian…... 3.25



Fried “Mooozadel”

(4) 7.95

Sliced fresh off the block, breaded and fried golden. Served with fresh made marinara


Long Island Lasagna Bombs

(5) 8.95

Fresh lasagna slices breaded and fried golden. Served with fresh made marinara


Garlic Knots

(6) 5.95   (12) 9.95

Served with fresh made marinara


Mama’s Baked Meatballs

(3) 8.95

Fresh made meatballs Mama’s way, covered in fresh made marinara & mozzarella


Italian Garlic Cheese Bread


Sliced Italian bread with garlic oil spread & oregano topped with mozzarella


“Bada Bing” Wings
(6) 6.95     (12) 12.5     (24) 22.5

Traditional crispy fried bone-in wings

~ Mild ~ Buffalo Ranch ~ Hot ~ Chipolte BBQ ~ Sweet BBQ ~ Parmesan Garlic ~ Plain

~Original Buffalo ~ Mango Habanero ~ Spicy Honey Garlic ~



~ Ranch ~ Italian ~ Caesar ~ Blue Cheese ~ Honey Balsamic ~ Greek Vinaigrette ~

Half Salad ….. 6        Add Chicken .... 2.5

Full Salad ….. 9         Add Chicken ...… 4

Long Island House Salad

Fresh greens, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, black olives & croutons.


Caesar Salad

Fresh romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan & croutons



Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes & basil drizzled with EVOO & balsamic glaze


Greek Salad

Fresh greens, tomatoes, onion, kalamata olives, banana peppers & feta cheese


Papa Joe’s Antipasto

Fresh bed of greens topped with pepperoni, ham, salami, provolone, roasted rep peppers,

artichoke hearts, black & green olives




Stuffed with Ricotta, Parmesan & Mozzarella & Finished with Garlic Oil

~Served with Fresh Made Marinara~

Create Your Own
(Sm) 9.95   (Lg) 14.95 

2 Free Toppings

(Additional Charge for Each Extra Topping)


Specialty Calzone

(Sm) 11.95   (Lg) 16.95

Buffalo Chicken

Italian Job

Stuffed Lasagna

Chicken Parmesan



Stuffed with Mozzarella & Finished with Garlic Oil

~Served with Fresh Made Marinara~

Create Your Own

(Sm) 9.95   (Lg) 14.95

2 Free Toppings

(Additional Charge for Each Extra Topping)


Specialty Stromboli

(Sm) 11.95   (Lg) 16.95

Buffalo Chicken

Italian Job

Stuffed Lasagna

Chicken Parmesan

Create Your Own Pizza

Small 10"

(4 Slices) - 7.99

Toppings 1.50 Each

*Premium Toppings 2.50 Each*

Medium 14"

(6 Slices) - 11.99

Toppings 2.00

*Premium Toppings 3.00*

Large 16"

(8 Slices) - 13.99

Toppings 2.50

*Premium Toppings 3.50*

Gluten Free 14"

(6 Slices) - 11.99

Toppings 2.00

*Premium Toppings 3.00*











Baked Chicken*

Crispy Chicken*


Genoa Salami*



Sautéed Onion


Fresh Garlic

Green Pepper



Roasted Red Pepper


Banana Pepper

Green Olive

Black Olive


Kalamata Olive*



Sun Dried Tomato*



Artichoke Heart*


Extra Mozzarella*




Fresh Mozzarella*



Vegan Cheese*


Specialty Pizza

Red: Fresh Pizza Sauce & Mozzarella


Sm 12    Md 16    Lg 19

Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, chopped garlic & fresh made marinara.

Finished with fresh basil, parmesan & EVOO drizzle

5 Boroughs

Sm 12    Md 16    Lg 19

A blend of 5 delicious cheeses! Mozzarella, parmesan, asiago, feta & provolone


Garlic Knot Pie

Sm 12    Md 16    Lg 19

Our pizza with fresh made garlic knots baked on to the crust & seasoned to

perfection! Served with sides our fresh made marinara


North Morris Ave

Sm 13    Md 17    Lg 20

Crispy eggplant, ricotta cheese, capers, sundried tomatoes, & chopped garlic.

Finished with fresh basil, parmesan & EVOO drizzle.


Strong Island

Sm 13    Md 17    Lg 20

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham & bacon



Sm 13    Md 17    Lg 20

Pepperoni, crispy chicken, chopped garlic, ricotta cheese & jalapenos.

Finished with red chili flakes



Sm 14    Md 18    Lg 21

Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives & sautéed onion


Brothers Baked Ziti Pizza

Sm 14    Md 18    Lg 21

Our fresh made baked ziti topped on a crisp garlic crust with fresh mozzarella

& rows of marinara. Finished with parmesan & basil



White: Garlic Oil Crust & Mozzarella

(No Red Sauce)


Pesto Perfecto!

Sm 12    Md 16    Lg 19

Crispy chicken, mushrooms, sautéed onions & ricotta cheese

Finished with fresh basil pesto & red chili flakes


Whitestone Bridge

Sm 12    Md 16    Lg 19

Ricotta cheese & mozzarella  Finished with parmesan & EVOO drizzle 


Pizza Caprese

Sm 12    Md 16    Lg 19

Fresh Mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil drizzled with EVOO and balsamic glaze


Boogey Down Buffalo Chicken

Sm 14    Md 18    Lg 21

Baked chicken, blue cheese & chopped parsley topped with mozzarella


Blazin BBQ Chicken

Sm 14    Md 18    Lg 21

Baked chicken, sauteed onion, jalapenos & bacon tossed in sweet BBQ sauce

topped with mozzarella and provolone


Times Square Pizzas

~Cut into 12 Square Slices~


Suffolk County Sicilian


Traditional thick square pizza

Grandma Sadie


Thin crust square style pizza with rows of fresh made marinara & mozzarella.

Finished with oregano & fresh basil




First comes the mozzarella, then the sauce on top of a thick square pizza.

Finished with EVOO and parmesan  




~ Prepared in Freshly Made 12" Italian Bread ~

Chicken Parmesan   9.95

Eggplant Parmesan   9.95

Meatball Parmesan   9.95


Sausage Parmesan   9.95


Long Island Expressway   10.95

Sausage, peppers & sautéed Onions tossed in fresh made marinara topped with provolone cheese


Jones Beach   10.95

Fresh mozzarella, artichoke hearts, tomatoes , roasted red peppers on garlic toasted Italian bread

topped with basil pesto & fresh greens  


Belt Parkway   10.95

Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, melted fresh mozzarella, topped with fresh  greens served

with honey balsamic


Great Bambino   10.95

Sliced Genoa salami, pepperoni, capicola, & provolone, topped with shredded lettuce, onion &

tomatoes. Served with Italian dressing.  Your preference Hot or Cold

Philly Cheese Steak   11.95

We may be from New York, but we sure know how to make a mean Philly!



Pasta Dinners

~ Served with Bread ~ Add side salad (1.50)


Spaghetti   11.95

Served with meatballs or sausage


Baked Ziti   11.95

Ziti pasta mixed with ricotta, fresh made marinara & mozzarella then baked


Baked Ravioli   11.95

Cheese filled pasta baked with fresh made marinara and mozzarella

Lasagna   12.95

Stuffed with meat sauce & ricotta cheese


Chicken Parmesan   13.95

Tender hand breaded chicken breast baked with fresh made marinara & mozzarella

served over spaghetti or ziti


Eggplant Parmesan   13.95

Tender hand breaded eggplant baked with fresh made marinara & mozzarella

served over spaghetti or ziti





Cannoli   2.95


Chocolate Cannoli   3.50


NY High-Rise Cheesecake   5.95


Tirimisu   5.95


Limoncello Mascarpone Cake   5.95


Catering Menu

~ Order Needs to be Placed 3 Days in Advance ~

*Half Tray Serves 5-8

*Full Tray Serves 10-14

Sautéed Broccoli

Half     30

Full     45


Half     30

Full     45

Ziti & Broccoli

Half     35

Full     60

Spaghetti & Meatballs

Half     35

Full     60

Baked Ziti

Half     40

Full     65

Baked Ravioli

Half     40

Full     65

Sausage & Peppers

Half     45

Full     70

Eggplant Parmesan

Half     50

Full     75

Chicken Parmesan

Half     50

Full     75

Eggplant Rollatini

Half     50

Full     75


Half     55

Full     80

House Salad

Half     20

Full     35

Caesar Salad

Half     25

Full     40

Antipasto Salad

Half     35

Full     50